Pit Barrel Cooker 18.5"
Last Updated
First Published
The Pit Barrel Cooker is the smoker for people who think smoking is too hard. It uses a dead-simple hook-and-hang system that produces competition-quality results with almost no technique required. Almost nobody is reviewing this properly.
What We Love
- +Virtually foolproof — hang meat and walk away
- +Consistent 275°F without adjustment
- +Vertical design fits in small spaces
- +Includes hooks, grate, and charcoal basket
- +Incredible ribs and chicken with zero effort
- +No damper fiddling or temperature chasing
Watch Out For
- −Limited to one temperature (~275°F)
- −Can't sear or high-heat grill
- −Smaller capacity than horizontal smokers
- −No thermometer — trusts the physics
- −Charcoal access is difficult during cooks
Specifications
Cooking Area
2 grates + 8 hooks
Diameter
18.5 inches
Material
Porcelain-coated steel
Fuel
Charcoal + wood chunks
Weight
57 lbs
Warranty
Limited lifetime
The Full Review
The Pit Barrel Cooker breaks every rule of traditional smoking — and it works brilliantly. There are no dampers to adjust, no water pan to fill, no temperature to chase. You load charcoal in the basket, light a small portion, hang your meat on hooks, and close the lid.
The physics of the vertical drum design naturally regulates temperature to around 275°F. It's slightly hotter than traditional low-and-slow, but the hanging position means fat renders down over the meat continuously, producing incredibly juicy results.
Ribs are the revelation. Hang a full rack from a hook, close the lid, and come back in 3 hours. No wrapping, no spritzing, no 3-2-1 method. Just done — with a bark and tenderness that rivals any smoker I've used.
Chicken is even better. Hang a whole chicken from a hook and the vertical position renders the skin crispy while the meat stays moist. It's the best whole chicken I've produced on any cooker.
The trade-off is flexibility. You can't sear, you can't cook at 225°F for traditional low-and-slow, and you can't really adjust temperature. It does one thing — smoke at 275°F — and it does it flawlessly.
How Does It Compare?
At a glance against its closest drum smoker rivals.
| Grill | Rating | Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pit Barrel Cooker 18.5" (this) | 4.7 | $399 | The hook-and-hang drum smoker that makes incredible BBQ with zero skill required. |
| Weber Smokey Mountain 18" | 4.8 | $399 | The competition-winning vertical smoker that punches way above its price. |
| Oklahoma Joe's Highland Offset | 4.4 | $349 | The entry point into real stick-burning. |
Who Is It For?
Beginners intimidated by traditional smoking. Busy cooks who want set-and-forget results. Anyone who's tried smoking and given up because of temperature management. Second-smoker buyers who want something effortless.
Final Verdict
The Pit Barrel Cooker is the most underrated smoker on the market. At $399, it produces results that would take years to master on a traditional smoker. If you think smoking is too hard, this will change your mind.
Check Price on Amazon