Last Updated
Ask any pitmaster the best smoker under $500 and you'll get one of two answers: the Weber Smokey Mountain (WSM) or the Pit Barrel Cooker (PBC). They take wildly different approaches to the same problem — and that approach difference is the whole story.
Quick Verdict
The Weber Smokey Mountain 18" ($399) is the better choice for low-and-slow precision and long unattended cooks. The Pit Barrel Cooker ($419) is the better choice for set-it-and-forget-it weeknight ribs and chicken with almost no learning curve. Both punch way above their price.
The Contenders
Weber Smokey Mountain 18"
$399
Cooks who want precise temperature control and long, low-and-slow brisket and pork shoulder cooks
Check PricePit Barrel Cooker Classic
$419
Cooks who want zero-fuss weeknight smoking with no temperature babysitting
Check PriceCategory Breakdown
Ease of Use
Winner: Pit Barrel CookerThe PBC wins, and it's not close. There's one vent setting, you light a chimney of charcoal, dump it in, hang the meat from hooks, close the lid. It cruises at 275-310°F for 6-8 hours. The WSM has three intake vents to manage and benefits from a water pan strategy. Once you learn the WSM it's easy, but day-one PBC is genuinely set-and-forget.
Temperature Control
Winner: WSMThe WSM wins. With its three intake vents and water pan, you can hold 225°F within 5°F for 12+ hours. The PBC runs in a fixed 275-310°F range — perfect for ribs, chicken, and shorter cooks, but you can't dial it down for a 16-hour brisket. For competition-style low-and-slow, WSM is the choice.
Cooking Capacity
Winner: Pit Barrel CookerPBC fits 8 racks of ribs hanging vertically — more than the WSM's two grates can hold. For pork shoulders or whole chickens hanging from hooks, the PBC's vertical orientation is genuinely brilliant. The WSM's two-grate setup is better for briskets, butts, and side dishes you want to keep flat.
Build Quality
Winner: WSMWSM has the edge. Porcelain-enameled steel body, durable plastic legs, the Weber 10-year warranty. The PBC is powder-coated steel — solid but more prone to rust at chips, and it carries only a 1-year warranty. WSMs routinely last 15+ years; PBCs typically need replacement at the 7-10 year mark.
Cold-Weather Performance
Winner: WSMWSM wins with a welding blanket. The double-wall construction and water pan make it the more forgiving smoker in winter. The PBC's single-wall barrel loses heat fast in wind and cold — workable but you'll burn through more charcoal. For Northern climates, the WSM is the smarter buy.
WSM 18 vs WSM 22 Against the Pit Barrel Cooker
Weber sells the Smokey Mountain in more than one size, and which one you compare against the Pit Barrel Cooker changes the answer. The Pit Barrel Cooker Classic is a single 18.5-inch drum — there is no larger or smaller Classic to choose between — so the decision is really "which WSM."
Capacity. The WSM 18 gives you two round grates; the WSM 22 gives you the same two-grate layout on a noticeably wider diameter. Against the Pit Barrel, the WSM 18 is roughly comparable for a family cook, while the WSM 22 is the one that clearly out-holds the barrel for flat cooks — multiple pork butts, a packer brisket that does not need trimming to fit, or a full load of chicken laid flat. The Pit Barrel keeps its own capacity advantage for anything you can hang: ribs, chickens and shoulders on hooks use vertical space the WSM does not have.
Footprint. The Pit Barrel and the WSM 18 both sit comfortably on a small patio or balcony landing. The WSM 22 needs real space around it and is heavier to move once loaded, which matters if the smoker gets stored in a shed or garage between cooks.
Fuel use. A bigger cook chamber takes more charcoal to bring up to temperature and hold there, so the WSM 22 burns more fuel per cook than the WSM 18 for the same amount of meat. If most of your cooks are two racks of ribs, the 18 is the more economical pick. The Pit Barrel sits between them: it runs hotter by design, which shortens cooks and offsets some of the fuel it uses.
Brisket. This is the clearest dividing line. A full packer brisket is awkward on the WSM 18 — most cooks trim it, roll it, or bend it against the edge of the grate. The WSM 22 takes a packer flat without gymnastics. The Pit Barrel handles brisket by hanging or on its grate, but the fixed higher running temperature makes it less suited to a long, tightly controlled brisket cook than either WSM.
Ribs. The Pit Barrel wins outright: hanging racks vertically lets it hold far more ribs than either WSM grate layout, and the fixed temperature range is close to ideal for ribs with no vent management at all.
Family cooking vs large cooks. For a household of four cooking most weekends, the WSM 18 or the Pit Barrel are both right-sized, and the choice comes down to precision versus simplicity. For parties, holidays, and anything where you are cooking for a crowd off one fire, the WSM 22 is the version of the Weber worth the extra money — and the version that beats the Pit Barrel on raw volume for flat cooks.
Final Verdict
Buy the Weber Smokey Mountain if you want to do real low-and-slow brisket cooks, live in a cold climate, or want a smoker that will outlast your kids. Buy the Pit Barrel Cooker if you want the easiest possible smoking experience for ribs, chicken, and pork shoulder with zero learning curve. Both are exceptional under $500 — neither is a wrong answer.
Buying Advice
If this is your first smoker and you mostly want ribs and chicken, get the PBC. If you have any pitmaster ambitions or you live north of the Mason-Dixon line, get the WSM. Both have devoted communities and excellent forum support.
