Last Updated
First Published
If you're shopping at the Weber charcoal counter, you're probably staring at two icons: the 22-inch Original Kettle and the Weber Smokey Mountain (WSM). Same brand, similar price range, completely different cooking philosophies. After running both for two full seasons, here's the honest breakdown.
Quick Verdict
The Weber Kettle ($175) is the better first charcoal purchase for 90% of buyers — it grills, sears, and smokes capably. The Weber Smokey Mountain ($399) is the better dedicated smoker — it produces competition-quality results but can't grill at all. If you only buy one, get the Kettle.
The Contenders
Weber 22" Original Kettle Premium
$175
All-around charcoal cooking — grilling, searing, and occasional smoking
Check PriceWeber Smokey Mountain 18"
$399
Serious low-and-slow smoking with rock-steady temps for 12+ hours
Check PriceCategory Breakdown
Versatility
Winner: Weber KettleThe Kettle wins decisively. It sears steaks at 700°F+, grills burgers at 500°F, and with a Slow 'N Sear or Snake Method setup, smokes a brisket at 225°F for 14 hours. The WSM does exactly one thing: smoke. You cannot grill a steak on a WSM — there's no high-heat zone, no direct cooking, no way to sear. It's a smoker, full stop.
Smoking Performance
Winner: Weber Smokey MountainThe WSM wins decisively here. The dedicated water bowl, vertical chamber design, and three precise vents make it brain-dead easy to hold 225°F for 12+ hours. The Kettle can smoke beautifully with the right setup, but it requires more attention — refueling more often, managing vents more carefully. The WSM is the choice that wins competitions for a reason.
Cooking Capacity
Winner: Weber Smokey MountainThe 18" WSM offers 481 sq in across two racks — enough for two pork butts or four racks of ribs simultaneously. The 22" Kettle offers 363 sq in on a single grate. For dedicated smoking sessions, the WSM holds significantly more meat. For day-to-day grilling for a family of four, the Kettle is plenty.
Ease of Use
Winner: Weber KettleThe Kettle is dead simple — light coals, dump them in, cook. The WSM has a bit more setup (water bowl, two grate levels, three vents to manage) but rewards you with set-it-and-forget-it stability. For day-one beginners, the Kettle is more approachable. For long unattended cooks, the WSM is easier to manage once dialed in.
Value
Winner: Weber KettleThe Kettle at $175 is the best value in all of grilling — there's nothing else under $200 that can do what it does. The WSM at $399 is also excellent value, but it's more than double the Kettle's price for a single-purpose tool. If budget is tight, the Kettle wins. If you specifically want to smoke and have the budget, the WSM is worth every dollar.
Final Verdict
Buy the Weber Kettle if you want one charcoal cooker that does everything well. Buy the Weber Smokey Mountain if you've already got a grill and want to add serious low-and-slow smoking capability. Most people should start with the Kettle — and if smoking becomes a passion, add a WSM as cooker number two.
Buying Advice
If you're a brand-new charcoal cook, do not buy the WSM first. You'll learn fire management on the Kettle in a way the WSM doesn't teach you. Once you've grilled a hundred burgers and smoked a few briskets on a Kettle, then decide if you need a dedicated smoker. Most people who buy both end up using the Kettle 80% of the time anyway.
