Last Updated
First Published
The Weber Kettle is the world's most popular charcoal grill. The PK Grill (Portable Kitchen) is the cult favorite that obsessive grillers swear by. Both are simple, both are legendary, and both have passionate defenders. Let's settle this.
Quick Verdict
The PK360 ($399) is the better grill for experienced charcoal cooks who want superior heat retention and airflow. The Weber Kettle Premium ($175) is the better value and starting point. The PK is refined; the Weber is iconic.
The Contenders
Weber 22" Kettle Premium
$175
First-time charcoal buyers, budget-conscious cooks, and anyone who wants the most versatile $175 grill in existence
Check PricePK Grills PK360
$399
Experienced charcoal enthusiasts who value cast aluminum construction and superior two-zone cooking
Check PriceCategory Breakdown
Heat Retention
Winner: PK360The PK360 wins handily. Cast aluminum holds heat far better than the Weber's porcelain-enameled steel. This means more consistent temperatures, less charcoal consumption, and better performance in cold weather. In my Minnesota winters, the PK held 225°F with noticeably less fuel than the Weber.
Two-Zone Cooking
Winner: PK360The PK360's capsule shape was designed for two-zone cooking — the elongated design creates a clear hot zone and cool zone. The Weber's round shape works for two-zone, but the distance between zones is shorter. For reverse searing and indirect cooking, the PK's geometry is superior.
Versatility & Accessories
Winner: WeberThe Weber Kettle has the largest accessory ecosystem of any grill — Slow 'N Sear, KettlePizza, rotisserie kits, and hundreds of third-party add-ons. The PK360 has growing accessory options but can't match the Weber's ecosystem. If you love modifying and expanding your setup, the Weber wins.
Durability
Winner: PK360The PK360's cast aluminum won't rust — ever. It's impervious to weather. Weber Kettles will eventually rust, especially in humid climates, though the porcelain enamel slows this significantly. A PK Grill from the 1960s still works perfectly. A Weber from the 1960s is likely a planter by now.
Value
Winner: WeberThe Weber Kettle at $175 is one of the best values in outdoor cooking — period. The PK360 at $399 is excellent for what you get, but it's more than double the Weber's price. The Weber delivers 90% of the cooking performance for 44% of the cost.
Final Verdict
The PK360 is the objectively better grill — better heat retention, better two-zone geometry, and rust-proof construction. But the Weber Kettle at $175 is such absurd value that it's impossible not to recommend. Start with the Weber. If charcoal becomes your passion, upgrade to the PK.
Buying Advice
Buy the Weber Kettle Premium ($175) + a Slow 'N Sear ($110) for $285 total. That combo gives you 85% of the PK360 experience for $114 less. When (not if) charcoal grilling consumes your life, add the PK360 as your second charcoal grill.
