Last Updated
First Published
PK Grills has been making the same cast aluminum grill since 1952 and people still pay $400+ for one. Weber's Jumbo Joe is a $99 18-inch kettle that handles tailgates and small backyards. They look completely different and they cook completely differently — here's which one is right for you.
Quick Verdict
Buy the PK300 ($399) if you want a lifetime grill with true two-zone capability and rust-proof cast aluminum construction. Buy the Weber Jumbo Joe ($99) if you want a portable charcoal grill for tailgates, beach trips, or apartments and aren't ready to spend $400.
The Contenders
PK Grills PK300
$399
Charcoal enthusiasts who want a heirloom-quality grill with rust-proof cast aluminum and excellent two-zone cooking
Check PriceWeber Jumbo Joe
$99
Tailgaters, apartment cooks, and beach trippers who need affordable portable charcoal that just works
Check PriceCategory Breakdown
Build Quality
Winner: PK300PK300 uses thick cast aluminum that literally cannot rust — there are 50-year-old PKs still in service. The Jumbo Joe is porcelain-enameled steel, durable but eventually shows surface rust after years of weather exposure. The PK is the heirloom; the Jumbo Joe is the workhorse.
Two-Zone Cooking
Winner: PK300PK's rectangular shape with four vents (two top, two bottom) creates a genuinely usable hot zone and cool zone — bank coals to one side and you get true reverse-sear capability. The Jumbo Joe's round design with single bottom vent makes two-zone possible but less precise. For people who care about steakhouse technique, PK wins decisively.
Cooking Area
Winner: PK300PK300 has 300 sq in; Jumbo Joe has 240 sq in. Both fit roughly 12-15 burgers. For tailgating both are plenty. The PK is more rectangular, which is better for whole racks of ribs; the Jumbo Joe is round, better for a single packer brisket curled up.
Portability
Winner: Jumbo JoeJumbo Joe wins decisively. It's 25 lbs with a built-in lid latch and carrying handle — toss it in a trunk. The PK300 with cart is 60+ lbs; without cart it's still 30+ lbs and awkward to carry. For actual portability the Weber is the right tool.
Value
Winner: Jumbo JoeJumbo Joe wins on pure dollars — $99 vs $399 is 4x. But amortized over a 50-year PK lifespan, the PK costs $8/year while three Jumbo Joes over the same period cost $300. Both are great values for different buyers.
Final Verdict
PK300 is the better grill; Jumbo Joe is the better deal. If you want a permanent backyard charcoal grill that'll outlive you, buy the PK. If you want portable charcoal that fits any budget, buy the Jumbo Joe.
Buying Advice
Don't try to make one grill do both jobs. Most charcoal enthusiasts eventually own a [Weber Original Kettle 22](/compare/weber-original-kettle-vs-master-touch) for the backyard plus a [Smokey Joe](/review/weber-smokey-joe) or Jumbo Joe for travel. The PK fits a different niche — it's for people who want one premium charcoal grill for life. Read our full [PK300 review](/review/pk-grills-pk300) for the deep dive.
