Last Updated
First Published
Solo Stove made its name with smokeless fire pits, and now they're coming for Weber's throne with a charcoal grill that promises less smoke and cleaner cooking. Can a fire pit company really challenge the most iconic grill ever made?
Quick Verdict
The Weber Kettle ($175) is still the better grill for serious cooks. The Solo Stove Grill ($399) is a better experience for casual grillers who hate smoke in their face. The Weber cooks better food; the Solo Stove creates a better vibe.
The Contenders
Solo Stove Grill
$399
Casual grillers, patio entertainers, and anyone who hates smoky clothes
Check PriceWeber 22" Kettle Premium
$175
Serious charcoal cooks who want maximum control, versatility, and the world's best grill ecosystem
Check PriceCategory Breakdown
Smoke Management
Winner: Solo StoveSolo Stove's double-wall airflow system genuinely reduces smoke. Standing next to it is noticeably more pleasant than a Weber. But here's the catch — smoke equals flavor. The Weber's smoke hits your food directly, creating that unmistakable charcoal taste. Solo Stove reduces smoke to your face but also reduces smoke on your food.
Cooking Performance
Winner: WeberThe Weber wins on cooking performance. Better vent control, better heat zones, better temperature range. The Weber's one-touch cleaning system and ash management are refined over 70 years. Solo Stove's grate setup is more limited, and temperature control relies more on charcoal management than vent precision.
Design & Aesthetics
Winner: Solo StoveThe Solo Stove is gorgeous — stainless steel, modern lines, conversation-piece design. The Weber Kettle is iconic but admittedly dated-looking. If your patio is curated and you want a grill that looks like sculpture, Solo Stove wins. If you want your grill to look like a grill, Weber wins.
Versatility
Winner: WeberThe Weber is infinitely more versatile. Smoking, indirect cooking, rotisserie, pizza oven attachments, wok cooking — the Weber Kettle can do it all with the right accessories. The Solo Stove is primarily a direct-heat griller with limited indirect capability and a small accessory ecosystem.
Value
Winner: WeberThe Weber at $175 is less than half the Solo Stove's $399 price tag while being a more capable cooker. The Solo Stove's premium goes toward materials, design, and smokeless technology — not cooking performance. For pure grilling value, Weber is unmatched.
Final Verdict
Buy the Weber Kettle if you care about cooking performance, versatility, and value. Buy the Solo Stove Grill if you prioritize a smokeless experience, stunning design, and don't need advanced grilling techniques. The Weber makes better food; the Solo Stove makes a better patio centerpiece.
Buying Advice
Honest advice: buy the Weber Kettle ($175) and a Solo Stove fire pit ($200-350) separately. You get the world's best charcoal grill AND a beautiful smokeless fire experience for around the same price as the Solo Stove Grill alone.
