Last Updated
First Published
If your charcoal budget tops out around $300-400, these are the two grills everyone debates. The Akorn is a steel-bodied kamado with insulation and great fuel efficiency. The Weber Kettle is the most iconic charcoal grill on Earth. Both are great. They're great at different things.
Quick Verdict
Buy the Char-Griller Akorn ($299) if low-and-slow smoking is your main goal and you want kamado-style fuel efficiency cheap. Buy the Weber Kettle ($219) if you want the most versatile, durable, time-tested grill in the world.
The Contenders
Char-Griller Akorn
$299
Budget cooks who want kamado-style smoking without spending kamado money
Check PriceWeber Original Kettle Premium 22
$219
Versatile grillers who value the proven workhorse with the best long-term durability
Check PriceCategory Breakdown
Smoking Performance
Winner: AkornAkorn wins. The insulated double-wall steel body holds low temps with kamado-like efficiency — 12+ hour cooks on a single load are easy. The Weber Kettle smokes great with a Slow N Sear, but you're refilling charcoal every 4-5 hours.
High-Heat Grilling
Winner: WeberWeber wins. The Kettle's wide-open design is unbeatable for direct grilling — sear marks, char, fast cooks. The Akorn can grill but the smaller, deeper firebox makes it less ideal.
Durability
Winner: WeberWeber wins decisively. A Weber Kettle outlasts everything. People are still using 30-year-old Kettles. The Akorn's painted steel rusts at the seams within a few years if not babied.
Versatility
Winner: WeberWeber wins. The accessory ecosystem (rotisseries, Slow N Sears, pizza stones, griddle inserts) makes the Kettle do more things than any other grill. The Akorn is mostly a smoker.
Value
Winner: AkornAkorn wins narrowly for smoking-focused buyers — kamado-style efficiency at one-quarter the price of a real kamado. The Kettle is the better value for grilling-focused buyers.
Final Verdict
Buy the Char-Griller Akorn if you want a budget smoker with great fuel efficiency. Buy the Weber Kettle if you want the most versatile, durable charcoal grill ever made — and one you'll still be using in 20 years.
Buying Advice
Honestly, the right answer for most people is to buy the Weber Kettle plus a Slow N Sear ($120). You get the world's best grill plus great smoking performance, and you spend roughly the same as the Akorn while getting something that will last forever.
