Last Updated
First Published
Two very different approaches to affordable charcoal grilling. The Weber 22" Kettle ($175) is the world's most popular grill. The Kamado Joe Jr. ($399) is a compact ceramic that punches way above its size. Here's how they stack up for first-time charcoal buyers.
Quick Verdict
The Weber Kettle ($175) is the better first charcoal grill — more cooking space, lower price, and a massive accessory ecosystem. The Kamado Joe Jr. ($399) is the better second grill or the right choice for small-space cooking with premium heat retention.
The Contenders
Weber 22" Kettle Premium
$175
First-time charcoal buyers who want maximum versatility and value
Check PriceKamado Joe Jr.
$399
Apartment balconies, small patios, and charcoal lovers who want ceramic performance in a compact size
Check PriceCategory Breakdown
Cooking Space
Winner: WeberThe Weber's 363 sq in main grate dwarfs the KJ Jr.'s 148 sq in. The Kettle handles a full family cookout — burgers, dogs, corn, and chicken simultaneously. The KJ Jr. fits 2 steaks, a handful of burgers, or one spatchcocked chicken. For feeding a family, the Kettle wins easily.
Heat Retention
Winner: KJ Jr.Ceramic beats steel — the KJ Jr. holds temperature with minimal charcoal and minimal airflow adjustments. It's rock steady at 225°F for smoking and reaches 700°F for pizza. The Weber requires more charcoal and more active vent management, especially in cold weather.
Portability
Winner: TieThe KJ Jr. at 68 lbs is heavy for its size but has a sturdy stand. The Weber Kettle is 32 lbs and genuinely portable. However, the KJ Jr.'s compact footprint fits on small apartment balconies where a 22" Kettle might not. Size vs weight is the tradeoff.
Fuel Efficiency
Winner: KJ Jr.The KJ Jr. sips charcoal — a handful of briquettes lasts hours. The Weber burns through fuel 2-3x faster, especially during long cooks. For smoking, this matters significantly. A full-day smoke on the KJ Jr. uses $3 in charcoal; the Weber might use $10-12.
Value & Ecosystem
Winner: WeberThe Weber at $175 is half the KJ Jr.'s price and has the largest accessory ecosystem of any grill. Slow 'N Sear, KettlePizza, rotisserie — hundreds of add-ons. The KJ Jr. has limited accessories. For pure value and expandability, the Weber is unbeatable.
Final Verdict
The Weber Kettle is the better first charcoal grill for most people — more space, lower cost, and infinite expandability. The Kamado Joe Jr. is ideal for small spaces, fuel-conscious smokers, or as a companion to a larger grill. Both are excellent products.
Buying Advice
Start with the Weber Kettle. If you fall in love with charcoal cooking and want a compact smoker for your patio table or a travel companion, add the KJ Jr. later. Together, they cover every charcoal cooking scenario imaginable.
