Last Updated
First Published
Both grills hit the same sweet spot: 4 burners, premium build, around $1,500. The Weber leans on brand legacy and parts availability. The Broil King leans on cooking horsepower and the unique dual-tube burners. Real cooks debate this one constantly.
Quick Verdict
Buy the Weber Genesis E-435 ($1,499) if you want the proven Weber experience with the best parts ecosystem in gas grilling. Buy the Broil King Regal S490 Pro ($1,399) if you want more BTUs, the dual-tube burner system, and a heavier feel for less money.
The Contenders
Weber Genesis E-435
$1,499
Cooks who want a proven 4-burner Weber with sear station and side burner
Check PriceBroil King Regal S490 Pro
$1,399
Cooks who want maximum BTU output and Broil King's dual-tube Linear-Flow burners
Check PriceCategory Breakdown
Heat Output
Winner: Broil KingBroil King wins. 50,000 BTUs main + 15,000 side + 18,000 rotisserie significantly outpaces the Genesis. The dual-tube burners also produce more even heat across the grates.
Build Quality
Winner: TieTie. Both are heavy 304-stainless premium builds with cast iron grates. The Broil King feels heavier; the Weber feels more refined. Both will last 15+ years.
Parts & Long-Term Support
Winner: WeberWeber wins decisively. Spirit and Genesis parts are at every hardware store and online retailer for decades. Broil King parts are available but harder to source 5-10 years down the line.
Smart Features
Winner: WeberWeber wins. Weber Connect integration, optional probes, and a more polished app. Broil King has zero smart features.
Value
Winner: Broil KingBroil King wins. $100 cheaper for more BTUs and a heavier feel. If you want maximum cooking horsepower per dollar, Broil King is the smarter buy.
Final Verdict
Buy the Weber Genesis E-435 if parts availability and smart features matter and you'll keep the grill 15+ years. Buy the Broil King Regal S490 Pro if you want more cooking power and don't mind smaller parts ecosystem.
Buying Advice
If you can pop into Home Depot for a $30 burner replacement in 2035, that's a real benefit. If you're buying based on raw cooking capability, Broil King wins on the spec sheet.
