Last Updated
First Published
The Blackstone 36 created the modern outdoor griddle category and remains the bestseller. The Camp Chef Flat Top Grill 900 challenges with thicker steel, removable grease cups, and convertible grill grates. Which big griddle is the better buy?
Quick Verdict
Buy the Blackstone 36 ($379) if you want the proven category leader with the deepest accessory ecosystem. Buy the Camp Chef Flat Top Grill 900 ($699) if you want premium build, convertible grates, and a serious upgrade.
The Contenders
Blackstone 36-Inch Griddle
$379
Griddle cooks who want the proven category leader with massive accessory ecosystem
Check PriceCamp Chef Flat Top Grill 900
$699
Premium buyers who want thicker steel, convertible grates, and removable grease cups
Check PriceCategory Breakdown
Cooking Surface
Winner: Camp ChefCamp Chef wins. Thicker cold-rolled steel holds heat better and resists warping. The Blackstone is good but thinner steel can warp under high heat.
Versatility
Winner: Camp ChefCamp Chef wins decisively. Removable grates convert it from griddle to traditional grill. Blackstone is griddle-only.
Grease Management
Winner: Camp ChefCamp Chef wins. Removable grease cups make cleanup easier than the Blackstone's fixed catch tray.
Accessory Ecosystem
Winner: BlackstoneBlackstone wins decisively. Hoods, side tables, covers, tools — the largest aftermarket of any griddle brand. Camp Chef ecosystem is much smaller.
Value
Winner: BlackstoneBlackstone wins decisively. $320 less for the proven griddle. Camp Chef's premium goes to features that matter to serious cooks but not casual users.
Final Verdict
Buy the Blackstone 36 if you want the proven category leader at a great price. Buy the Camp Chef Flat Top Grill 900 if you want the upgraded build and convertible grates.
Buying Advice
Blackstone is the safer choice for first-time griddle buyers — accessories are everywhere and resale value is strong. Step up to Camp Chef if you've owned a griddle before and know exactly what you want.
