Last Updated
First Published
Traeger's Ironwood 885 and Weber's SmokeFire EX6 are both premium WiFi-enabled pellet grills targeting the $1,500-2,000 range. One is from the company that invented the pellet grill. The other is from the most trusted name in grilling. Here's which one earns your money.
Quick Verdict
The Traeger Ironwood 885 ($1,799) has better software and more consistent pellet feeding. The Weber SmokeFire EX6 ($1,599) has better searing capability and Weber's legendary build quality. Both are excellent — your choice depends on whether you prioritize smoking or grilling versatility.
The Contenders
Traeger Ironwood 885
$1,799
Dedicated smokers who want the best app experience and set-and-forget reliability
Check PriceWeber SmokeFire EX6
$1,599
Grillers who want pellet convenience with direct-flame searing capability
Check PriceCategory Breakdown
Smoke Quality
Winner: TraegerThe Traeger produces slightly more consistent smoke at low temperatures (180-225°F). Its super smoke mode circulates extra smoke during the critical first hours. Weber's SmokeFire produces good smoke but some users report a milder flavor profile. For pure smoking, Traeger has the edge.
Searing & Grilling
Winner: SmokeFireWeber wins decisively. The SmokeFire's Flavorizer bars and open flame access allow direct-flame grilling up to 600°F — closer to a gas grill experience. The Traeger Ironwood maxes out around 500°F with indirect heat only. If you want one grill for both smoking and searing steaks, Weber is the clear choice.
App & Technology
Winner: TraegerTraeger's WiFIRE app is more polished with guided cooks, community recipes, and a large content library. Weber Connect works well but has fewer features and a smaller community. Both allow remote temperature monitoring and adjustment. For the tech-focused cook, Traeger wins.
Build Quality
Winner: SmokeFireWeber's construction is heavier gauge with better weather resistance. The SmokeFire feels like a Weber — solid, substantial, and built to last. Traeger's Ironwood is well-built with double-wall insulation but uses thinner steel in some areas. Both have good fit and finish, but Weber's heritage in metalwork shows.
Value
Winner: SmokeFireThe Weber SmokeFire EX6 at $1,599 is $200 cheaper than the Traeger Ironwood 885 while offering better searing and build quality. Traeger justifies its premium with superior software and smoking performance. Dollar for dollar, Weber gives you more grill for the money.
Final Verdict
If your primary use is low-and-slow smoking, buy the Traeger Ironwood. The super smoke mode and superior app make it the better dedicated smoker. If you want a versatile cooker that smokes AND grills with direct flame, buy the Weber SmokeFire. It's the better all-arounder at a lower price.
Buying Advice
Consider what you cook most. If 80% of your cooking is brisket, ribs, and pulled pork — Traeger. If you split between smoking weekends and grilling steaks on weeknights — Weber SmokeFire. Both are premium products you'll keep for a decade.
