Last Updated
First Published
The ChefsMate and the Cabo sit next to each other in every marine catalogue at almost the same price, in the same 316 stainless, on the same mount system. Buyers reasonably assume they are the same grill in two shapes. They are not — the shape is the point.
Quick Verdict
The Cabo's rectangular grate is more useful for burgers, steaks and fillets. The ChefsMate's round kettle shape holds heat better with the lid down and suits roasts and whole fish. Cabo for most people; ChefsMate if you cook with the lid closed.
The Contenders
Category Breakdown
Usable Grate Space
Winner: CaboBoth quote similar square inches, but a rectangle fits food better than a circle. The Cabo takes four burgers in a row without the awkward edge gaps the ChefsMate's round grate creates. In practice you get noticeably more usable area from the Cabo despite similar specs.
Lid-Down Cooking
Winner: ChefsMateThe ChefsMate's domed kettle circulates heat the way a kettle grill does ashore. Whole fish, a small chicken, thick chops — anything that needs indirect heat comes out better on the ChefsMate. The Cabo's shallower lid is fine for melting cheese and not much more.
Wind Resistance
Winner: ChefsMateThe deeper kettle body shelters the burner better, and the ChefsMate keeps cooking in a breeze that has the Cabo struggling. Neither matches the Catalina 2's infrared plate, but between these two the round body wins.
Stowage
Winner: CaboThe Cabo's flatter body packs into a locker more efficiently. The ChefsMate's dome wastes space in a way that matters on a small boat where the grill shares a lazarette with fenders and lines.
Value
Winner: ChefsMateThe ChefsMate costs $40 less and shares the same alloy, warranty and mount compatibility. If lid-down cooking suits how you eat aboard, it is the better buy of the two. If you grill flat food fast, the Cabo earns its premium.
Final Verdict
Cabo if you cook burgers, steaks and fillets — which is most boat cooking. ChefsMate if you close the lid and cook whole fish and roasts aboard.
Buying Advice
Both take the identical Magma mount, so the mount decision is independent of the grill decision. Measure your rail or rod holder first, then pick the body shape that matches how you cook.